Star Trek Stamps

I recently watched the newest Star Trek movie, Section 31. As a huge fan of Star Trek, I was incredibly excited to see Philippa Georgiou return in this exploration of the enigmatic Section 31. I'm the kind of fan who appreciates all corners of the Star Trek universe, even the less celebrated entries. I always find something to enjoy, whether it's a thought-provoking theme, a compelling character, or simply a fun space adventure.

Unfortunately, Section 31 left me deeply disappointed. I started watching with high hopes, but the story quickly faltered. After 40 minutes, I paused the film, hoping a fresh perspective the next day might improve my opinion. Sadly, it did not.

The narrative felt shallow and predictable. The stakes never truly felt high, and the Emperor's motivation for aiding Section 31 remained unconvincing. The flashbacks to Georgiou's youth, while initially intriguing, ultimately lacked emotional weight.

The biggest disappointment, however, lay with the Section 31 operatives themselves. This supposed team of elite agents, tasked with saving the Federation, was a collection of underwhelming caricatures.

• Melle, the Deltan "lover," met an early and ultimately insignificant demise.
• Zeph, clad in an exoskeleton, resembled a brute with little intelligence, more akin to a nightclub bouncer than a sophisticated operative.
• Quasi, the chameloid shapeshifter, was paralyzed by indecision, offering little to the story or his own character development.
• Alok Sahar, the Augment leader, was perhaps the most believable, though his creation felt somewhat one-dimensional.
• Fuzz, a nanokin controlling a Vulcan robot, was a jarring departure from Vulcan demeanor, loud, impulsive, and ultimately distracting.
• Rachel Garrett, the Starfleet officer intended to provide a moral compass, felt flat and unconvincing, especially considering her eventual rise to Captain.

The film felt overly reliant on Michelle Yeoh's portrayal of Philippa Georgiou, yet even her performance was limited to primarily action sequences. The complex and treacherous Georgiou we knew from Discovery was largely absent.

Furthermore, the special effects felt surprisingly cheap, a far cry from the visual quality we've come to expect from modern Star Trek productions.

Ultimately, Section 31 is a significant misstep for the franchise. The story was weak, the characters were poorly developed, and the production values were underwhelming. I struggle to identify its target audience. It likely alienated established fans while offering little to entice new viewers. As a Star Trek production, it should have aspired to something more than just mindless entertainment. Unfortunately, for the first time ever, I couldn't find even one positive thing. Which makes me very sad. 😢

Check out other Star Trek articles in the blog section.